I love engaging in uncomfortable conversations and intellectual debate. I had one of those conversations with some of my colleagues while discussing servant leadership—the admirable philosophy of putting your team’s needs before your own to help them grow and accomplish the mission. It’s what I believe leaders should strive for, and it’s the bedrock of my Lead Last philosophy and the foundation of my most recent YouVersion Bible Plan: Upside-Down Leader.
We all agreed that the best leaders are those who embody servant leadership, living it out in their daily actions instead of simply talking about it. The conversation became uncomfortable when we began defining and writing down the behavioral competencies, or “soft skills,” associated with servant leadership, such as empathy, active listening, humility, and a commitment to others’ growth.
That’s when we all looked at each other and wondered: Could too much of this make you a soft leader?
When Could Servant Leadership Be Counterproductive?
What’s interesting is that each of us has had the opportunity to lead many people in diverse environments, yet we couldn’t agree on a simple “yes” or “no.” One of my colleagues gave a “yes, but…” answer, suggesting that without a contrasting quality like “command presence,” our team members may exploit the perceived vulnerability (i.e., “soft sills”). He concluded that servant leadership is ineffective—or even counterproductive—without command presence.
This was a compelling argument because none of us wants to be seen as weak, easily manipulated, or “pushovers,” especially in professional leadership. However, after some thought, I offered a slightly different perspective: The line between servant leadership and command presence isn’t as profound as it seems. It’s a mutually supportive relationship in which the qualities that make us effective servant leaders build our command presence.
This isn’t just semantics; it’s a critical reframing of how we think about the power of service.
Command Presence is Built, Not Born
To address the critique, let’s first define command presence.
Command presence is the leader’s ability to project confidence, credibility, and authority in a way that earns trust and compels respect. It’s not about stoicism or intimidation; it’s the culmination of competence, character, and composure under pressure. Your team trusts your judgment, believes in your intentions, and feels secure in your ability to guide them through uncertainty.
While many, especially those of us in military circles, define this using external traits like “bearing” or “decisiveness,” I break it down into the Five Cs for sustained impact:
- Confidence without Arrogance: Projecting certainty in yourself, your decisions, and the mission.
- Composure Under Stress: Remaining calm, steady, and decisive under challenging circumstances.
- Credibility through Competence: Being a lifelong, diverse learner who understands the mission environment and how each team member fits into the big picture.
- Character and Authenticity: Consistently demonstrating integrity, humility, and consistency in word and action.
- Care: Prioritizing your team’s health, welfare, and resources.
Here’s the key takeaway: The “soft skills” of servant leadership are the foundation that strengthens every one of these Five Cs. They don’t diminish your authority; they reinforce it.
Why Service Creates Authority
When leaders fear being “soft,” they often lean on hierarchy, control, and positional authority. The key here is that this creates compliance but not commitment. Servant leadership, however, enhances your command presence because your authority becomes rooted in trust, credibility, and authenticity. Here are a couple of examples:
- Empathy and active listening (servant skills) lead to composure and credibility (presence): A leader who truly listens understands the problem better and earns the right to be heard. When you eventually make the tough, unpopular call, your team knows it came from a place of deep understanding, not ego or self-interest. You are calm because you are informed.
- Humility and commitment to others’ growth (servant skills) lead to character and confidence (presence): A leader who invests heavily in their team’s professional development demonstrates care. That care builds loyalty. When the pressure is on, team members trust your intentions completely, reinforcing your presence.
A Marine who demands high standards but dedicates time to mentor his or her junior leaders, or a CEO who makes a tough layoff decision but communicates transparently and invests in the remaining staff, is not soft. They are demonstrating immense strength.
The Hard Edge of Servant Leadership
If you haven’t noticed by now, servant leadership is not passive; it is active, intentional, and demanding. It requires courage to put others first, humility to listen, and the confidence to lead with authority and empathy.
A servant leader still:
- Holds people firmly accountable to high standards.
- Makes hard, sometimes unpopular decisions that benefit the mission.
- Takes responsibility when things go wrong.
The difference is that they do so with a mindset of stewardship rather than self-interest. They are “firm but fair,” and their discipline is rooted in care, not ego.
The Answer
So, does servant leadership make you soft? No. It makes you a leader of substance.
Your leadership presence won’t last if it only comes from authority. But if it’s rooted in service and defined by the posture of leading last, it will endure even in the most challenging professional moments.
Author’s Note:
Join me: I’ve created a free 30-day plan on the YouVersion Bible App called The Upside-Down Leader that guides you on building this kind of counterintuitive strength.
Start the 30-Day Plan Today: [bible.us/r/FwE]
Leave a Reply